Friday

November 20, 2026 Vol 122

Unpopular Opinion: Dead Poets Society is a beautiful, seductive lie

By SUSAN BRUXVOORT LIPSCOMB
Updated 11:50 p.m. EDT, 18 Nov 2026

Consider a scenario. A new teacher at an elite boys’ school creates a cult following among his students, encouraging them in minor acts of vandalism, violations of school rules and general defiance of the ethos of the institution. He encourages them to follow their adolescent impulses, tacitly endorsing their use of tobacco and pornography.

One of his students, following the teacher’s instruction to “seize the day,” realizes that his desires conflict with those of his parents. When he turns to the charismatic teacher to discuss the problem, the teacher encourages his belief that sacrificing his desires would be a tragic compromise of authenticity.

Feeling trapped, the student takes his own life. The teacher is blamed for the suicide and loses his job. The boys he has indoctrinated mourn his departure and salute him as a hero.

This is the plot of Dead Poets Society, a beautiful film that nonetheless tells dangerous lies about charismatic adults, adolescent emotion and personal autonomy.

Dead Poets Society is easy to love. It has beautiful cinematography, a compelling script and strong acting. Robin Williams (in the middle of his career) and Ethan Hawke (at the beginning of his), give moving performances.

Last November, the Star ran a review of Dead Poets Society, which concluded: “The muted autumn hues of New England, the haunting soundtrack and the quiet intensity of the performances create a reflective atmosphere. Every frame feels intentional, enhancing the film’s emotional depth.”

I agree that these elements engage viewers’ emotions and make the film easy to enjoy. But they also seduce the viewer into believing several lies.

Lie #1. Thinking for yourself goes hand in hand with defying authority and breaking rules.

The teacher, Mr. Keating, teaches his students that the method of poetry promoted in their textbook (a mathematical analysis) is not only unproductive but stupid. He orders the students to tear the relevant pages out of their textbooks. He hasn’t taught them to think for themselves about this approach to poetry. He’s led them in an act of vandalism based on his own perspective.

Lie #2. As a young person, following your desires is the most important thing you can do. If your ability to follow your desires is restricted, this is tragic.

Keating’s student Neil Perry (portrayed by Robert Sean Leonard) discovers that he is passionate about theater and wants to become an actor. His parents, especially his father, do not want him to do this; they want him to go to Harvard Medical School. When Neil gets a role in a local production of A Midsummer Night’s Dream (forging his father’s name on a permission form), his father is enraged and commands him, the day before the performance, to drop out of the play.

At this point, Neil goes to Mr. Keating and asks his advice. Mr. Keating’s response is unhelpful: he says, “Have you ever told your father about your passion for acting? Have you ever showed him that?”

Keating tells Neil that he is not being true to himself, that he is putting on an act for his father, “playing the part of the dutiful son.” Mr. Keating’s recommendation to Neil is to double down on his pursuit of authenticity. He says, “You have to show him who you are, what your heart is…You prove it to him by your conviction and your passion. You show him that.”

Neil sees the truth: “I’m trapped,” he says. He understands that Mr. Keating has put him in an impossible situation, that avowing his love of acting will not move his father.

Later, Neil lies to Mr. Keating, telling him that he talked with his father and that his father gave him the go-ahead to appear in the play. Neil cannot be the hero of self-expression Keating pushed him to be, so he lies to save face with his mentor.

This sets the stage for the climactic tragedy of the movie. When his father sees Neil in the play, he tells Neil that he is enrolling him in a military academy. This prompts Neil to commit suicide.

The script writers constructed this scenario, of course, to appeal to the emotions of viewers. It teaches us more about our yearning for simple fables than about the world. Neil’s father is so cruel and unfeeling. He puts Neil in such an awful position. Mr. Keating, the teacher, is so warm and understanding. He’s the only one who “gets” Neil.

But what if Mr. Keating had made a phone call to the director of the play and checked to see if there was an understudy to take the part? It’s not unprecedented that a teenager can’t act in a high school play. What if Mr. Keating had said: “Neil, I know that not being able to act in this play is a terrible disappointment, but you’re going to have other opportunities. I’m sure that Harvard has great theater clubs. You can go along with your father’s wishes for the moment. There will be time to act later if this is something that’s really important to you.”

That intervention or that conversation would have made a less-heartrending film. But they would be healthier ways for an influential teacher to interact with a vulnerable young man.

Lie #3. The best teachers are the charismatic ones who say pithy things that students quote to one another and who win their students’ adoration by their surprising and entertaining classroom manner.

Mr. Keating is the kind of teacher whom students describe as “amazing” in course evaluations. He stands on his desk, takes students outside on impromptu field trips and fosters an emotional response to the world.

His students find out that, when Mr. Keating was a student, he was part of a secret group called “The Dead Poets Society.” The students want to be just like Keating. So they recreate this society, which mainly involves going to a cave at night, smoking, looking at dirty pictures and reading some poetry out loud. These behaviors are pretty typical for immature adolescents—probably things (other than the poetry reading) that these boys would have been inclined to do already. Shouldn’t a teacher inspire them to grow beyond their adolescent impulses?

Mr. Keating also tells his students that they need to look at the world from a different perspective (climbing on top of his desk) and march to their own beat (taking them for a walk in the courtyard of the school). But in neither of these lessons do the students gain analytical tools that might help them form independent judgements; they are led to see the world exactly as Mr. Keating sees it. They each hop up on the desk exactly as he has done and end up marching around the courtyard, not to their own beat, but exactly in sync with Mr. Keating and with each other.

Mr. Keating doesn’t model independent thinking. He teaches conformity to one particular way of thinking: the Romantic expressivism that transformed American culture in the 1960s.

I loved this movie when I saw it in a theater at 14. It appealed to my emotions and gave me clear heroes (Mr. Keating, Neil Perry) and villains (the headmaster, Neil’s father).

As I’ve had more experiences with schools and with adolescents (as a professor and a mother) and as I’ve reflected more about how adults should guide young people, I’ve come to believe that this movie does not present a healthy model of teaching or mentorship.

I encourage you to watch Dead Poets Society. But don’t let the messages of the film wash over you. Talk about the movie with friends and parents and teachers. What true things does this movie tell you? But also: what does it get wrong? ★ 

Houghton STAR

The student newspaper of Houghton University since 1909.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *