Friday

November 20, 2026 Vol 122

Christian Nationalism is Pagan

By BEATRICE BROOKS ’27 and JOEL ROCHA ’29

COURTESY OF SAMANTHA RENKEN
COURTESY OF SAMANTHA RENKEN

In last week’s opinion piece, “I Am a Christian Nationalist,” Jacob Schick and Zach Lynet quoted John Adams’ words, arguing that the American Constitution only works for a moral and religious people — namely, Christians.

However, the call of Jesus isn’t simply a “moral” or “religious” call, as Schick and Lynet claimed. It is a call to a different kind of life. Christ calls us out of what the pagan powers of the world consider to be normal and into a new kind of life altogether.

The Apostle Paul describes our new Christian life as one in which we are “crucified with Christ” (Gal. 2:19). This means that our lives are shaped by service and sacrifice for others, just as Jesus’ life and death was for us. We might call this a “cruciform” or “cross-shaped” life. It is a life shaped by love for those who don’t deserve it, care for the least of these (Mt. 25:20) and humble servant leadership rather than tyrannical control (Mk. 10:43–45).

Christianity is, in fact, the reversal of all pagan power structures that seek to control others through tyranny, discrimination, hatred and even violence.

Christian nationalism, on the other hand, is explicitly pagan. It perverts the gospel of Christ into a means of political power and dominance, stripping people of their human dignity and God-given autonomy. It worships the pagan gods of power, money, racism, hatred and misogyny instead of the God of the Bible, whose power is made perfect in weakness (ahem, the cross) and whose Kingdom is exemplified by diversity and love.

Don’t hear what I’m not saying. Christians should vote for whatever party seems best to them, red or blue, according to thoughtful research, biblical study and the fellowship of a community of believers working through the challenges of twenty-first-century politics together.

I really do agree that it is the Christian duty to vote with Christian values. But it is not the Christian duty to perpetuate a rhetoric of exclusion, fear, racism and male supremacy, as Christian nationalism so often does. This is the true Christian nationalist agenda: a pagan agenda.

Not only is Schick and Lynet’s argument based on a pagan understanding of the gospel, but it also draws from a well of poor historical and political understanding of America. The foundation of the United States was certainly influenced by a form of Christianity, albeit very different from modern American Christianity. However, Schick and Lynet are under the false assumption that, because of this, it was our founders’ intention to create a Christian nation. It was not.

To understand this, it is important to understand that the Constitution is not a religious document; it is a political document. The founders did not intend to write a religious document. Rather, they wrote a political document that defends the freedoms of its people, including the freedom of religion. This can be seen primarily in the First Amendment, which prohibits Congress from establishing a national religion and protects the free exercise of religion and also in Article VI, which explicitly prohibits religious tests as qualifications for federal public office. There is no “myth” of the separation of church and state; the concept of separation is literally baked into our Constitution. That is why it allows for us to be led by non-Christian leaders. It is un-American and undermines freedom — a core American value — to argue for a national religion.

It is also important to understand that Christians’ national identity comes after their religious identity. We are Christians who happen to be American, not Americans forced to be Christian because of our citizenship or residency. As Christians who happen to be American, we should live as Jesus would have lived, welcoming those from other religions as children of God and doing our best to guide them toward the Christian faith. That is our Great Commission: to make disciples in gentleness, not to force our beliefs onto others.

Christian Nationalists present a God that is unwelcoming of those who do not fit our conception of Christianity. Their “gospel” claims that we are to reject those who differ from us religiously and not love them. That is not Christianity. Jesus loved and lived with the misguided, the rich, the poor, those who were welcomed by society and those who were not. That is how we are to live. We should not try to make a purely Christian nation. Instead, we should try to make a Christian world, and we prevent the possibility of that by not allowing for religious freedom and individual choice in our own country.

Some people use their individual freedoms to follow violent, extremist religions and I’m certainly not arguing in favor of this. However, a religion like Islam, which Christian Nationalists most commonly refer to as one such violent religion, is far more nuanced than just the extremists. We prevent America from being as free as it could be, and we prevent Christians from reaching those whom they need to when we judge one vast religion by the actions of minority extremist sects. By not allowing for religious freedom, we become un-American; by prioritizing our nation first above our duty to God, we also become un-Christian.

It is clear that Christian Nationalism misrepresents both the fundamental principles of the American project, and of the Christian faith. Christ’s very teachings and sacrificial death condemn the mission of Christian Nationalism. Rather than exercising power over others, Jesus demonstrates weakness by becoming human (1 Cor. 1:18 and Phil. 2:6–11), accepting people who had once been excluded or demeaned (Rom. 11) and offering himself as a sacrifice for the undeserving (Lk. 9:23). Likewise, we are taught to lay ourselves down for other people rather than to domineer. We are obligated to work for the good of everyone who lives in America. And we must love all — even the people society tells us to deport or to silence. ★

Beatrice is a senior studying Bible & Theology and History, with plans to be a pastor in the Wesleyan-Methodist tradition. She enjoys granny hobbies, preaching, and studying feminism and theology. 

Joel is a sophomore double majoring in Political Science & Philosophy and English, and a minor in Theology. He enjoys running, camping, and reading about various topics. 

Houghton STAR

The student newspaper of Houghton University since 1909.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *